Color Wow Dream Coat vs Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray

When it comes to achieving glossy, high-shine hair, Color Wow’s Dream Coat Supernatural Shine Spray and Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray are two of my favorite products, but they deliver that shine in completely different ways.

Dream Coat is known for its humidity-blocking, glass-hair effect that lasts through multiple washes, whereas Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray is all about instant gratification; it’s a style finisher that adds a lightweight, reflective finish once you’re finished styling your hair.

They’re similar in some ways, but different in others, so one will probably make more sense for specific hair routines than others, and a select few may prefer to use both together.

Below, I compare how each product works, before and after results, price, and how to choose the right one based on your hair goals, whether that’s long-lasting smoothness or ultra-glossy, polished shine to help you pick the best product for your hair.

color wow dream coat vs extra mist-ical shine spray review

color wow dream coat supernatural spray results

The Color Wow Dream Coat Supernatural Shine Spray gives you that viral, glass-like sleek and shiny hair a la Kim Kardashian. It’s ultra-lightweight formula adds tons of shine, heat protection, and actually tames frizz. Formulated with a unique anti-humidity complex, this is also the best hair product on the market for protecting your hair against humidity and extra moisture in the air.

I’ve shared a full-length review of Dream Coat, as well as the Extra Strength version, but for a quick, tl;dr: what I love most about Dream Coat is that it actually works. It makes your hair is noticeably shinier and softer; it’s my must-have hair product anytime I travel because it genuinely keeps your hair from getting frizzy and unruly, especially if you are going somewhere that has lots of hard water.

The main downside is that Dream Coat is technique-dependent. It’s not one of those hair products where if you use it somewhat well, you get some results; you have to execute each step correctly in order for it to work. The key is to blow dry with tension (like a blowout) in order to activate the formula, which gives your hair that sleek finish. Even though I love air-drying my hair, Dream Coat is worth breaking out the blow dryer because it will last you 2-3 washes. So while it’s more work up front, the results last longer - a high maintenance step to let your hair be more low maintenance, if you will.

It costs $30 per bottle and while you need to fully coat your hair, one bottle lasts months, so it’s one of the most cost-effective products on the market that actually delivers noticeable results.

pros

  • Offers legit humidity protection (acts like a water-repellent "raincoat”)

  • Long-lasting (multi-wash)

  • Creates a sleek, polished finish and you actually notice (and feel) the results

  • Truly a lightweight formula

  • Doesn’t build-up

  • Minimal fragrance; ideal if you are sensitive

  • Offers heat protection

  • Makes your hair way less frizzy

cons

  • Requires heat styling; you also have to make sure you’re adding tension for full results

  • Can feel flat on super-fine hair

  • Technique matters a lot; it’s a more high-maintenance product in that way

color wow extra mist-ical shine spray results

The Color Wow Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray makes my hair noticeably shinier and softer. The scent is strong, but didn’t bother me surprisingly (I am super sensitive to fragrance and prone to migraines).

Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray is ideal if you hate the greasy feeling of a serum or oil, or just don’t need that extra hydration on styling days. It’s also perfect if you have a special event or want your hair to pop in photos; this made my hair look like I got it done at a salon, and all it took was a quick spray, so it’s easy to use and fast, too.

If you prefer low maintenance routines and a hair gloss or serum is too much work, you may really love Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray. A little goes a long way, so one bottle will last you a while. And while it’s in an aerosol container, this was not drying in the slightest. It also contains a heat protectant, so if you need to go back and touch-up your hair later on, you don’t have to worry about damage. In fact, the heat will also enhance the shine even more, which is nice.

It isn’t meant to tackle frizz, but I did find that my hair looked a little more tame without sacrificing volume. But again, if you use too much it’ll give your hair a slightly greasy look and feel. Safe for all hair types and fine-hair-friendly, it’s not a necessary product in regards to hair health, but absolutely delivers on its promises of added shine and a glossy finish.

pros

  • Makes you hair noticeably shinier

  • Lightweight mist

  • Nozzle disperses product evenly and doesn’t get clogged

  • Works on straight or curled hair

  • Doesn’t dry your hair out

  • Ideal for special events or photos

  • Creates a smooth, polished look

  • Doesn’t flatten your hair or undo volume

cons

  • Temporary, superficial results that are gone when you wash your hair next; no long-term benefits

  • Doesn’t hydrate or repair

  • Can make your hair look/ feel greasy if you overapply, especially on fine hair

  • Does not combat frizz

  • Shine may be subtle on dark hair unless you add the second-heat step

  • Strong scent that can be overpowering

color wow dream coat vs extra mist-ical shine spray results

color wow dream coat vs extra mist-ical shine spray which is better?

Because you get shine and heat protection with both, the better product ultimately depends entirely on you styling process.

Dream Coat uses heat-activated polymers to seal the hair cuticle and block humidity, which is why results can last through several washes.

Choose Dream Coat if you:

  • Want long-lasting smoothness and frizz control.

  • Have frizz-prone, porous, or humidity-sensitive hair

  • Already blow dry your hair (or don’t mind adding in that step)

  • Want a style that will last for multiple days

  • Prefer to add styling products to the beginning of your routine, not the end

On the other hand, Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray is a true finishing product. While it doesn’t protect the hair or repair it, you get a true gloss-like finish that seals your style for the rest of the day.

Choose Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray if you:

  • Want instant shine and a polished finish.

  • Have already styled hair that needs a boost

  • Have fine hair that can’t handle oils or serums

  • Want an added shine boost for events, photos, or finishing touches

  • Just need a final step in your routine, not a base product

Dream Coat is the better product for you if you want a product that is anti-frizz and long lasting. If you want a visual, instant-results product, get Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray.

price

Dream Coat costs $30 and you get 6.7oz of product, meaning it costs $4.48 per ounce. The price of Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray is $29 for a 5oz bottle, which comes out to $5.80 per ounce. It’s a little hard to compare these two directly, because one is a mist (Dream Coat) that requires you to coat your whole head, whereas you just need a light mist of the Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray to complete your look.

Based on my personal experience with each, Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray is cheaper because you don’t need as much product, but the results aren’t long-lasting. If you see Dream Coat as an investment (as one usage will last 2-3 washes), then that’s the better value because it offers longer-lasting results.

ingredients and formula

Both are lightweight, ultra-fine mists that work on all hair types.

Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray is closer to a hairspray, but it is not sticky and doesn’t offer hold. I always joke that Dream Coat is magic because it feels like nothing in your hair. That said, if you don’t use heat and tension, it will also do nothing to your hair, so it’s a more finnicky formula.

Dream Coat is formulated with a proprietary anti-humidity complex that humidity-proofs, prevents frizz, adds shine, and provides heat protection.

On the other hand, the star ingredient of Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray is mullein, a light-producing flower that makes hair look radiant. It also has heat protectant in it.

finish and styling

Both products give you shine. That said, the main differences here are when you use each in the hair styling process:

  • Dream Coat is the first step of your styling routine, meant to be used on wet hair. It requires that you blow dry your hair, as the formula needs heat and tension in order to work. If you prefer to air dry, skip it.

    • It’s also best for sleeker looks, like blowouts and straight styles.

  • Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray is a finishing product, so you use it as your last step on already-styled hair.

    • If you alternate between beach waves, polished curls, and straight styles, get Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray as it compliments all of those styles well. That said, you only need the tiniest amount; too much will make your hair feel greasy or weighed down.

Also, if frizz is one of your main concerns, then Dream Coat is the product for you as it is specifically designed to tame frizz.

when to use both dream coat and extra mist-ical shine spray

If you’re a shine addict, you’ll love the look you get when you use both Dream Coat and Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray because they’re designed to complement each other.

Dream Coat gives your hair structure and locks in results for longer (2-3 washes); Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray is the finishing step that adds extra polish and glossy shine.

To use both:

Pairing them together will help you get that true “glass hair” look that is smooth and reflective, not just one or the other.

color wow dream coat vs extra mist-ical shine spray FAQ

what’s the difference between dream coat and extra mist-ical shine spray?

Dream Coat is a long-lasting styling treatment that transforms your hair structure as the first step of your styling routine. Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray is a finishing spray that enhances shine after you’re done.

which one gives more shine?

Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray gives instant, high-impact shine right away. Dream Coat gives a more subtle, glass-like sheen as part of a sleek finish. If you curl or wave your hair, you will find that Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray makes your hair shinier, but if you prefer blowouts or a straight style, Dream Coat is better.

can you use both together?

Yes; they actually complement each other well and give your hair insane shine without leaving a film or causing build-up.

Use Dream Coat as your first styling step, then finish with Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray for that ultra-glossy pop at the end.

which one is better for frizz?

Dream Coat is better for fighting frizz thanks to its unique anti-humidity formula. Extra Mist doesn’t fight humidity; it just adds shine.

will color wow extra mist-ical shine spray weigh hair down?

No. It’s an ultra-fine mist, so it distributes evenly without making hair greasy. My fine hair gets weighed down SO easily, but it truly feels like I have nothing in my hair whenever I use Dream Coat.

do you need extra mist-ical shine spray if you already use dream coat?

Not necessarily. Your hair will still have an enhanced glow after using Dream Coat, but if you want a reflective, bright shine, Extra Mist-ical Shine Spray will take that glow to another level.

beautyPaige DiTulliohairComment